The popularity of artificial intelligence tools like ChatGPT has exploded in recent months. This has led to some handwringing among trademark lawyers about whether AI is coming for their jobs.
So, I asked ChatGPT whether it was coming for me. Here’s its answer:
As of my knowledge cutoff in September 2021, AI like ChatGPT can’t replace trademark lawyers, though it can certainly assist them in their work. Trademark law involves complex legal analysis, interpretation of legal texts, understanding context, advising clients, and negotiation skills, which are areas that AI is not yet capable of handling at a level comparable to a trained human lawyer.
AI can help in certain tasks like:
- Preliminary trademark searches: AI can be used to perform initial searches of trademark databases to identify potential conflicts with existing trademarks.
- Legal research: AI can help automate some aspects of legal research, sifting through volumes of legal texts to identify relevant cases, laws, and secondary sources.
- Document review: AI can assist in the process of reviewing documents, which can be especially useful in the case of large volumes of documents.
However, AI lacks the ability to provide the critical, strategic thinking that comes with years of legal training and experience. Additionally, AI currently can’t understand the nuances of human emotions or the subtleties of negotiation.
It’s also important to remember that practicing law involves responsibilities that go beyond mere technical skills, such as maintaining attorney-client privilege, ethical obligations, etc. These are areas where AI, in its current state, can’t fully comply.
In short, AI can act as a valuable tool to assist lawyers, helping to automate some aspects of their work and potentially improving efficiency. But replacing human lawyers is not feasible with the AI capabilities we have as of 2021.
However, AI and machine learning are rapidly evolving fields. So, it’s always possible that future advances could further change the landscape of how AI is used in the legal profession. But even in such a case, it’s more likely that AI will end up working alongside humans, rather than replacing them entirely.
Well, that’s a relief! And it’s consistent with our experience at Trust Tree, where we strive to let computers do computer things and people do people things. Notably, we’ve been using AI tools for trademark searching since 2015. And while ChatGPT’s legal research limitations are well-documented thanks to these guys, it can be handy for non-legal research. So, for example, ChatGPT is good at explaining the different meanings that a trademark might have. This is handy for responding to Office Actions from the trademark office.
Of course, our experience at Trust Tree might be unique. We are a small, technology-focused law firm that provides flat fee services. Efficiency is the name of the game for our business. This is different from traditional law firms that rely on hourly billing. In those firms, it’s going to become increasingly more challenging to bill clients for hours of work that can be done by AI tools in a fraction of the time.